Physics 105N - How Things Work - Fall, 1996

Problem Set 2 - Answers



Problem 1: Chapter 3, Case 9a-e (Pg. 155)

A submarine hovers below the surface of the water, supported by the buoyant force. Although it also pushes on the water to propel itself forward and to adjust its height, the submarine’s most important depth control is its average density.

a. If a submarine is hovering motionless, 50 m below the surface of the water, what is the net force it’s experiencing?
Answer: Zero.
Why: Since the submarine is motionless, it isn't accelerating and must be experiencing a net force of zero.

b. What is the motionless submarine’s average density?
Answer: The same as that of water.
Why: For the upward buoyant force on the submarine to exactly balance the submarine's weight, the submarine has to have the same weight as the water it displaces. Its average density will then be the same as that of the water it displaces.

c. A submarine has ballast tanks that control its buoyancy. To start descending, the submarine floods these tanks with outside sea water. How does this flooding affect the submarine’s average density and the net force on the submarine?
Answer: The submarine's average density increases and the submarine begins to experience a downward net force.
Why: The submarine's mass increases while its volume remains constant. As a result, its average density (its mass divided by its volume) increases. Since it is now more dense than the water it displaces, the submarine experiences a net downward force.

d. To ascend, the submarine uses compressed air to purge the sea water from its ballast tanks. How does eliminating this sea water affect the submarine’s average density and the net force on the submarine?
Answer: The submarine's average density decreases and the submarine's net force becomes more upward.
Why: The submarine's mass decreases while its volume remains constant. As a result, its average density (its mass dividied by its volume) decreases. Since it is now less dense than it was before, it experiences a more upward net force (either a weaker downward net force than before or perhaps even an upward net force).

e. To control the submarine’s tilt, water is pumped between tanks in the front and back of the vessel. Why doesn’t this transfer of water affect the submarine’s buoyancy?
Answer: The submarine's average density doesn't change.
Why: The submarine's average density is its total mass divided by its total volume. Since neither its mass nor its volume change, its average density remains unchanged, too.

Problem 2: Chapter 4, Case 2a-e (Pg. 207)

A helicopter suspends itself from a spinning rotor. Each blade in the rotor is actually a wing, with an airfoil shape that creates lift as it slices through the air. To hover, the helicopter’s rotor creates just enough upward lift to exactly balance the helicopter’s downward weight.

a. The rotor keeps turning at a constant rate. To control the rotor’s lift, the helicopter adjusts the angles of attack of the blades as they turn. If a hovering helicopter increases the angles of attack of all of its blades simultaneously, what will happen to the forces on the helicopter and how will it move?
Answer: The helicopter's net force will become upward (its downward weight will remain unchanged but its upward lift force will increase) and it will accelerate upward.
Why: While the helicopter was hovering, its upward lift force exactly balanced its downward weight. By increasing the angles of attack of all its blades, it increases their upward lifts and thus its overall net force becomes upward. It accelerates upwardin response to this upward net force.

b. The helicopter can also adjust the angle of attack of a single blade. If it increases the angle of attack of whatever blade is currently on the pilot’s right, the helicopter will experience a torque about its center of mass. Which way will the helicopter begin to tilt?
Answers: Its right side will rise and its left side will descend.
Why: The blades to the helicopter's right will experience a larger upward lift force than before. Thus lift is exerted to the right of the helicopter's center of mass and exerts a torque on the helicopter about that center of mass. The helicopter will begin to rotate about that center of mass so that its right side will rise and its left side will descend.

c. If the helicopter is tilted nose down and tail high, the helicopter will begin to accelerate forward. Why?
Answer: The lift force experienced by the blades will have a component in the forward horizontal direction.
Why: While the helicopter is upright and its blades are turning in a horizontal plane, the blades experience a lift force that is directly upward. But while it's leaning forward, the blades are turning in a forward-tilted plane and they experience a lift force that is both upward and forward. The forward component of this lift force is the only horizontal force acting on the helicopter, so the helicopter accelerates forward.

d. To turn the helicopter so that it faces a different direction, something must exert a torque on it about a vertical axis. That’s one reason why the helicopter has a small rotor at the end of its tail boom. This rotor pushes air to the right or left, depending on the angles of attack of its blades. Which way should the tail rotor push the air to turn the helicopter to the right?
Answer: The tail rotor should push the air to the right.
Why: For the helicopter to turn to the right, its tail and tail rotor must move to the left. The tail rotor needs something to push it toward the left to cause this shift, so it pushes the air toward the right. The air pushes back and the tail rotor accelerates toward the left. The helicopter thus turns toward the right.

e. The rotor blades are actually flexible, but they extend almost straight outward when the rotor is spinning. Why?
Answer: When the blades are spinning around the central hub, they are accelerating inward and must thus be pulled inward by tension in the blades. This tension pulls the blades straight.
Why: Whenever a limp object experiences tension, it tends to straighten out. In this case, the tension is exerted on the blades by the hub pulling inward and the ends of the blades trying to go in straight lines. With inertia causing the blade tips to pull the ends of the blades away from the hub and the hub pulling the other ends of the blades toward the hub, the blades are under enormous tension and they pull straight.

Problem 3: Chapter 5, Case 2a-e (Pg. 247)

Modern Olympic athletes are aided by a variety of scientific advances. Here are a few examples of how science enhances performance in athletics.

a. A ski-jumper is suspended in a wind-tunnel, where a device measures the horizontal and vertical forces on him as air flows past him horizontally. The jumper arranges his body to obtain the most favorable forces for a long flight. Describe the most favorable horizontal and vertical forces.
Answer: The ski-jumper wants the least possible drag (or least backward horizontal force) and the greatest possible lift (or most upward vertical force).
Why: The ski-jumper flies through the air. By minimizing the slowing effects of (mostly horizontal) drag and maximizing the flight-prolonging effects of (mostly vertical) lift, the ski-jumper can extend this flight to great distances down the hill.

b. In cross-country skiing, the skier slides forward first on one ski and then on the other. The ski bottoms are coated with special waxes so that they exhibit large static frictional forces on snow but small sliding frictional forces. How does this difference in frictional forces allow the skier to use a stationary ski to push herself forward on a sliding ski?
Answer: The stationary ski experiences a stronger forward force of static friction while the sliding ski experiences a weaker backward force of sliding friction. The net force on the skier is thus forward and she accelerates forward.
Why: To accelerate forward, the skier needs a net forward force. If both skies experienced equal forces but in opposite directions, then she wouldn't accelerate at all. By experiencing a strong forward force on one ski and a weaker backward force on the other, she is able to accelerate forward.

c. Modern tracks are often constructed out of recycled rubber tires. The track surface is very resilient, deforming slightly when you push down on it and then bouncing back when you stop pushing. How does this surface improve runners’ times as compared to the dirt, gravel, or cinder tracks of long ago?
Answer: They return energy to the runners' feet as the feet rise upward after coming to a stop.
Why: Granular tracks cushion the impact of landing, but they extract energy from the runners' feet (the feet push downward on the dirt, gravel, or cinders and the dirt, gravel, or cinders move downward). This energy isn't returned to the feet as they rise upward. A rubber track still cushions the runners' feet, but it also returns energy to those feet as they rebound upward.

d. Bicyclists now use aerodynamically designed bicycles and clothing to minimize air drag. Bicyclists also "draft" one another, a strategy in which one bicycle follows immediately behind another bicycle, easing the rear bicycle’s passage through the air. If the front bicycle were so aerodynamic that it experienced no air drag at all, how would this affect the strategy of drafting and why?
Answer: Drafting would be of no value because the front bicycle won't have any affect on the air it passed through.
Why: The first bicycle experiences drag because the air pushes back on any object trying to move forward through it. Since forces come in equal but oppositely directed pairs, the bicycle must push forward on the air. This effect leaves the air moving forward on average. When the second bicycle encounters the forward moving air, it experiences less than the usual drag and has an easier time moving forward. If, however, the first bicycle experiences zero drag, the air behind that bicycle doesn't experience any forward force and is left unaffected by the first bicycle's passage. The second bicycle experiences no effect from the first bicycle's passage.

e. During a downhill ski race, the racer tries to keep her skies in contact with the surface at all times. Even if she remains in a tight, aerodynamic tuck position, she slows down whenever she becomes airborne after hitting a bump. Why does contact with the ground keep her moving forward as she races downhill?
Answer: She only experiences the downhill ramp force when she's in contact with the ground.
Why: The only forward force the skier experiences in the downhill ramp force that comes from her contact with the ground. This force is the result of her downward weight and the forward-tilted support force that the mountain slope exerts on her (it's at right angles to the slope, so it's upward and forward). When she is in the air, the only force she experiences along the slope is the backward force of drag. When when she is on the ground, she also experiences the small backward force of frictional force and this large forward ramp force.

Problem 4: Chapter 5, Case 8a-e (Pg. 248)

Fire extinguishers that use carbon dioxide gas can be used to fight all kinds of fires because carbon dioxide displaces air, doesn’t support combustion, settles downward on surfaces, and is non-toxic.

a. Each carbon dioxide molecule is heavier than an average air molecule. Why does carbon dioxide gas sink in air?
Answer: It is more dense than air when the two are at the same temperature and pressure.
Why: A carbon dioxide molecule weights more than the average air molecule. As a result, carbon dioxide gas that's at the same temperature and pressure as the air it displaces weighs more than the air it displaces and sinks.

b. The pressure inside the bottle of the extinguisher is so high—about 60 times atmospheric pressure—that most of the carbon dioxide inside it is liquid. This liquid turns to gas as you use the fire extinguisher. If you were to release the gas directly into the air through a narrow opening, why would the gas suddenly acquire a large forward velocity?
Answer: The air would accelerate toward the lower pressure(, so that it's velocity would increase in the forward direction).
Why: Gases and other fluids accelerate toward lower pressure. In this case, the lower pressure is on the far side of the narow opening. The carbon dioxide in the extinguisher accelerates through the narrow opening and leaves with a high forward velocity.

c. If you were to hold the extinguisher when the gas rushed out its nozzle, you would feel a strong backward force. Explain the origin of this force.
Answer: The fire extinguisher pushes the gas forward to make that gas accelerate out its nozzle and the gas pushes back on the fire extinguisher.
Why: Since the gas ends up with a large forward velocity, the fire extinguish must have pushed it forward. It, in turn, must have pushed backward on the fire extinguisher.

d. To reduce the force noted in c, a carbon dioxide fire extinguisher has a deflecting surface directly in the path of the carbon dioxide as it leaves the bottle. The carbon dioxide hits this surface and turns toward the right or left. Why does this surface allow you to use the fire extinguisher without being pushed backward?
Answer: Half the gas leaves the fire extinguisher heading to the right and half to the left. This gas has zero overall momentum. Since the overall momentum of the gas starts at zero and ends at zero, there has been no transfer of momentum between the fire extinguisher and the gas. They haven't pushed on one another on average!
Why: While the fire extinguish may move the gas around through its nozzle and deflecting plate, it eventually sends half of the gas in each of two opposite directions. These two streams of gas end up pushing against one another equally and there is no net force exerted on the fire extinguisher itself.

e. The fire extinguisher collects the swirling gas after it has been deflected by the surface and directs that gas toward the fire. Because the gas travels slowly after hitting the deflecting surface, it carries much less momentum and kinetic energy. What has become of the energy that was stored in the compressed carbon dioxide before it left the extinguisher?
Answer: It has become thermal energy.
Why: By allowing the gas to swirl around in turbulent flow and rub against itself in the process, the fire extinguisher has converted the gas's total energy (pressure potential, kinetic, and gravitational energies) into thermal energy.

Problem 5: Chapter 6, Case 6a-d (Pg. 292)

A typical electric oven has two separate heating elements: one on top and one on the bottom. The bottom element is used for baking while the top element is used to broil foods.

a. When only the bottom element is active and glowing red hot, what heat transfer mechanism carries most of the heat to the food in the oven?
Answer: Convection (or Radiation--they're both active).
Why: Convection proceeds strongy as heated air rises from the hot element.Radiation is also strong, although the surface character of the cooking pots determines how effective it is.

b. When only the top element is on, what heat transfer mechanism carries most of the heat to the food?
Answer: Radiation.
Why: Convection doesn't work when air is heated at the top. Only radiation carries heat from the top element to the food beneath it.

c. How does wrapping the food in shiny aluminum foil affect the rate of heat transfer to the food in these two cases?
Answer: The aluminum foil has little effect on convective heating, but it dramatically reduces radiative heating.
Why: Heat flows easily through aluminum foil so that its presence on the food doesn't slow convective heating much. But the aluminum foil reflects thermal radiation pretty well so that radiative heat transfer is very weak.

d. A convection oven has a fan that circulates air in the oven. How does the fan affect the rate of heat transfer to the food?
Answer: The forced circulation of air speeds up convective heat transfer dramatically.
Why: Rather than waiting for hot air to rise and carry heat to the food, a convection oven uses a fan to stir the air rapidly. The heated air carries its thermal energy quickly from heating element to food and the heat transfer is quite rapid.